In this episode, Payton explores the baffling disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit, a news anchor who vanished without a trace just outside her apartment.
Fox9 KMSP - https://www.fox9.com/news/jodi-huisentruit-winsted-search-no-remains
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58m9bdDlc6Y
Find Jodi - https://findjodi.com/the-team/
https://findjodi.com/jodis-early-beginnings-in-broadcasting/
News Nation - https://www.newsnationnow.com/missing/jodi-huisentruit-suspect-list-four-people-private-investigator/
https://www.newsnationnow.com/missing/jodi-huisentruit-search/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QW4ia-90Ehg
Star Tribune - https://www.startribune.com/iowa-officials-search-winsted-property-in-connection-with-disappearance-of-jodi-huisentruit/601181505
Independent - https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/crime/jodi-huisentruit-missing-new-search-b2650602.html
KTTC - https://www.kttc.com/2024/12/10/investigators-revisit-previously-dismissed-lead-jodi-huisentruit-case/
https://www.kttc.com/2024/12/27/private-investigator-shares-passing-figure-once-linked-with-jodi-huisentruit-investigation/
Dakota News Now - https://www.dakotanewsnow.com/2024/12/08/nonprofit-struggles-fund-search-missing-mason-city-news-anchor/?outputType=amp
Mason City, Iowa - https://www.masoncity.net/pview.aspx?id=17966&catid=481
Iowa Department of Public Safety - https://dps.iowa.gov/contact-dps
Biggest US Cities - https://www.biggestuscities.com/city/mason-city-iowa
Arizona’s Family 3 - https://www.azfamily.com/2024/06/28/answers-may-still-lie-arizona-case-iowa-news-anchor-who-went-missing-1995/
KCCI 8 Des Moines - https://www.kcci.com/article/jodi-huisentruit-missing-person-case-investigation-update-christopher-revak/63160204
WSAW TV - https://www.wsaw.com/2024/12/06/forgotten-wisconsin-cold-cases-christopher-revak-deadly-connections/
https://www.wsaw.com/video/2024/12/06/mason-city-pd-investigating-chris-revak/
Radio Iowa - https://www.radioiowa.com/2024/12/12/podcast-sparks-new-lead-in-case-of-long-missing-mason-city-woman/
Wisconsin Clearinghouse for Missing & Exploited Children & Adults - https://www.missingpersons.doj.wi.gov/sites/default/files/unsolved-cases/harm-deidre.pdf
Hey everyone, welcome back to the podcast. This is Murder with My Husband. I'm Payton Moreland.
And I'm Garrett Moreland.
And he's the husband.
I'm the husband.
Happy Monday! Hope everyone is having a great day. A couple of things—if you're an Apple subscriber or you're on Patreon, Garrett did secretly record a short 15-minute episode. You can go check that out. I am going to do a full episode at some point; that one was just kind of a little test to see how it is. He did it by himself.
Payton had no idea.
Clarify—Garrett told the story.
I told the story by myself. Literally by myself. Payton had no idea. It was kind of to relieve some stress off of her. You've just been busy with some things. So you can go check that out if you're a Patreon, Spotify, or Apple subscriber.
If you're not—no worries, no stress. I love you. But you don't get to listen to Garrett tell a story now, do you?
But I do need to do a full episode at some point, so we’ll see. We’re getting the works going with that.
Yeah, for my 10 seconds—I’m burnt. I am burnt like a red tomato. But that's okay, because that burn will turn into a tan, and that is all that matters. Hope everyone is having a great summer. Summer’s coming up, and we love you.
Alright, you guys, so before we get into today’s episode—it’s actually a little different and a little special. Let me explain. As you guys know, a while ago I started a solo show that is now called Into the Dark. It is a true crime show that every once in a while ventures into ghost, UFO, spooky stories—all things dark and mystery.
Again, it is majority true crime. I love Into the Dark, and it truly is my little baby. And I am going to beg you right now—please go follow Into the Dark. Please go turn on automatic downloads. Please subscribe. Do whatever—please, please, please help me grow Into the Dark and support the show.
I know you guys are awesome. I know I can always turn to you. So thank you so much for doing that right now.
That being said, this week we are going to drop one of my favorite Into the Dark episodes. Don't worry—it is still a true crime case, and it is one that genuinely blew the Into the Dark listeners away. So we thought Murder with My Husband needed to hear it.
If you do listen to Into the Dark, you might be a little sad, and we’re sorry. We will be back to regularly scheduled programming next week. And again, if you are curious, you can check out the Patreon episode if you want a kick of Garrett, because Garrett won’t be in this episode.
Also, there will be a Dear Daisy recorded this month, so Dear Daisies will be back.
Alright, you guys—we love you. Thank you for the support. This case is truly going to blow your mind, so let’s get into it.
Hey everyone, welcome back to the Into the Dark podcast. I am your host, Payton Moreland. I'm so, so happy that you are here listening. Thank you for your continued support—you guys, it means more than you will ever know.
I'm going to jump straight into my 10 seconds right now. Okay, if you know me at all, you know that I really only watch crime shows on TV. I've never really been a big reality TV person or series show fan. Honestly, I just love true crime and crime on TV.
CSI: Las Vegas is my favorite—I've watched it too many times to count. I love Law and Order: SVU, I love Criminal Minds, I love CSI: Miami. And I was thinking about Criminal Minds the other day, because I've kind of been on Criminal Minds TikTok, and I've watched it multiple times through.
But you need to let me know—there’s this phenomenon in Criminal Minds where you have Derek Morgan, who is just the idealistic perfect guy, right? Like, that’s his character in the show. He’s this hunk, he’s a hottie, he’s so... just everything you’d want.
But then there's this huge group of Criminal Minds watchers who are Team Reid. Okay? We love Spencer Reid. He is our crush in the show.
And it's so funny because, in the show, they make his character the opposite of Morgan. He's nerdy, he's skinny, he can’t shoot a gun—you know, all these things. But there are all these girls who love him.
So I want you to tell me in the comments—if you do watch Criminal Minds, are you a Morgan or Reid stan? Let me know. I will tell you right now, I am a bigger fan of Reid. But I obviously love Morgan. Still, I am a Reid girl. Okay? I am.
But yeah, I just thought that was a funny discourse I’ve been seeing going around, and I just wanted to know what you guys thought.
Alright, jumping into the episode. Unsolved cases are always frustrating. It’s difficult to get invested in someone’s story and want to learn what happened to them, only to be left with more questions than answers once the investigation is all said and done.
Well, I’m going to spoil today’s case right now—it is an unsolved disappearance. But you’re going to want to tune in, because in the past few months, the police have actually made some huge breaks in this case. And my hope is that before too long, we can change the narrative, we can find a solution, and get closure—and finally see this case get solved.
So let’s go back to the 1990s, when an ambitious young reporter was working her dream job. Her name was Jodi Huisentruit, and she was working for a television news station in Mason City, Iowa. It was called KIMT.
Mason City, in Iowa, was a decent-sized Midwestern town in the 1990s. It had a population of just under 30,000 people, meaning Jodi’s job was a great chance to reach a big audience and make a name for herself.
She was still young and early in her career—she was just in her 20s. And Jodi knew that in the years and decades to come, she had a lot of potential to go even further. But she’d have to push herself.
So, each time Jodi appeared on camera, she would ask the crew to make a recording of her performance. Now, in the early '90s, that was much harder to do than it is today. She had to talk to the people working in the recording booth, who were already busy filming, editing, and broadcasting everything live.
She’d ask them to do her the favor of making her a tape while they were also focused on making sure everything looked right. The good news was, though, that her coworkers in the booth were willing to help, and she collected dozens of tapes over the years—beginning with her very first appearances on her college’s student-run channel, all the way through her time with KIMT.
And the reason she was doing this was honestly kind of like game film. She would take each tape home and watch it. Then she’d make a note of each time she misspoke or maybe didn’t deliver a line perfectly—every moment when her smile slipped, or when her volume was a little too loud or quiet.
She was studying her film to get better. She was a perfectionist. She kept track of everything so she could improve in areas where she could, and then the next day, she would show up to work resolved to do better than she had the day before. Each broadcast, in her eyes, was a chance to knock things out of the park.
And honestly, all of that effort paid off. By 1995, Jodi was 27 years old and appearing on air regularly. She was fairly well known in Mason City and had honestly kind of become a local celebrity.
Now, since she was such a hard worker, it’s safe to say that it was out of character for Jodi to ever be late to work or to blow off a shift. But that is exactly what happened on June 27, 1995. And it's going to be very obvious if she doesn't show up to work—because she won’t be on air.
That day, in 1995, she was supposed to come in by 3:30 a.m. I know—that's very early—but Jodi was part of the morning news team. She had to be there by 3:30 to have enough time to prep for the broadcast that would begin live at 6:00 a.m. So it was a problem for her not to be in on time.
That day, there was no sign of her when her shift began. Jodi’s producer, a woman named Amy Coons, thought it was possible that Jodi might just be running late. It was too early for her to hit traffic, but maybe something else had held her up.
Except—by 4 a.m., Jodi still hadn’t made it into the station, and she was now half an hour late to her shift. So that’s when Amy, the producer, called Jodi to see what was going on.
And after a few rings, Jodi answered her home telephone. As it turned out, she had just overslept, and Amy had woken her up.
So Jodi, on the phone, is like, “No, no, no—I just overslept. I’m not in any kind of trouble or anything. Nothing bad has happened.” And nothing about Jodi’s tone of voice made Amy think she was lying. In fact, she sounded groggy, like the phone call had indeed woken her up.
Amy explained that she was reaching out because it was already 4:00 a.m., Jodi was late, and Jodi promised, “I’m going to hit the road as soon as I can. I’ll be in the office right away.” And then they hung up.
Now, Amy knew that Jodi only lived about a five-minute drive from the TV station, so it shouldn’t have taken her very long at all to make it in. Even if you assume that Jodi needed some time to get up, get dressed, brush her teeth, and do her hair and makeup, she still should have gotten there pretty quickly.
But after this phone call, a full hour passes—and Jodi still doesn’t show up.
By 5:00 a.m., Amy, the producer, calls again to ask what is going on. I mean, someone has to go on air that morning. This time, nobody answers at Jodi’s home. The clock was ticking, and Jodi was supposed to be live on air at 6:00.
There was no sign of her, and Amy knew that the station couldn't wait much longer. It's like they say: the show must go on. So Amy made the spur-of-the-moment decision to fill in for Jodi and do the broadcast herself. She sat at Jodi’s usual desk, read all of her lines, and by the time the morning news was finished, there was still no sign of Jod.
Jodi never came into work that day. By now, it had been three hours since Amy had supposedly woken Jodi up on the phone that morning, and Amy was extremely worried. It was one thing for Jodi to sleep in, but it was completely out of character for her to answer the phone, say she was coming in, and then not show up and miss an entire broadcast.
She had never blown off her work like this before. She cared too much about her job. And with Jodi still not answering the phone, Amy decides it is time to call 911 and ask the police to head over to Jodi’s home to do a welfare check—to see if she's okay.
As soon as Amy requested the wellness check, the investigators rushed over to Jodi’s apartment building. Before they even had a chance to get inside, they saw something very concerning. Jodi’s car was parked out front, and there were marks on the pavement. It kind of looked like someone had dragged something heavy across the ground.
On top of that, a bunch of Jodi’s personal possessions were scattered all around her parking spot. There were earrings, a blow dryer, and a pair of red high-heeled shoes that were just strewn across the ground by her car. Her car keys were also on the ground, but they had been bent, as though she was trying to get into the vehicle—when, before she could, something had happened and she got caught in a struggle.
The police also found a partial palm print on the handle of the car, like someone had tried to open the door. Maybe it was Jodi, or maybe it was someone else who had tried to get inside that morning. They haven't ever publicly confirmed whether they identified who the palm print belonged to.
Interestingly, there was also a hair at the scene, but the police haven't said whether they know whose hair it was either. So they have evidence that they still haven’t publicly identified.
But here's what I do know: the officers noticed all this, and obviously, we have the context that she was rushing to work. So these personal items in the parking lot aren’t actually that mysterious. It’s most likely that Jodi woke up, was in a rush, grabbed a bunch of her things she was going to need at the station to get ready for work, and something happened while she was trying to get into her car.
When the officers went into Jodi’s apartment, everything there seemed neat and tidy—unlike the parking spot. Her apartment looked exactly how it was supposed to, with one exception: in her bathroom, the toilet seat was up.
Which, if you live with a man or have a husband, probably means that a man was the last person to use it. Since Jodi didn't have any male roommates, this suggested that maybe someone else had been over the night before or early that morning. But the investigators obviously didn't know who.
Beyond that, there were no signs of forced entry or a struggle inside. So, given the state of the parking lot, their theory was that Jodi left her place rather quickly right after Amy called her—but she left of her own accord. She wasn't abducted from her apartment. She made it all the way out the door and was about to unlock her car when someone ambushed her and dragged her off.
So the crime scene isn’t necessarily inside Jodi’s apartment.
Now, while the police were reviewing the scene and gathering evidence, a man walked right up to the detectives and started talking to them. This obviously struck the officers as weird. There was no reason for him to be there—it’s not like there was an obvious crime scene happening—and he just seemed a bit too comfortable inserting himself into the investigation.
This man comes up, and they learn that his name is John Vanise. He was actually one of Jodi’s friends, despite the fact that he was in his late 40s—so nearly twice Jodi’s age. Apparently, they actually got along great, and John told the police that the two of them went on boating trips together pretty frequently.
So he’s sitting there talking to police, saying they were friends. Which is rather weird, that he just shows up when she happens to be missing—but I digress.
He admits to the police during this conversation that the night before, Jodi had actually been over at his apartment. Earlier that month, he had thrown her a party for her 27th birthday, and he had also filmed the gathering. According to John, last night he had invited Jodi over so they could watch the video of her party that he had made.
So, she had come over, they’d watched the tape, and then she headed back to her own place. In other words, John is basically telling officers that he’s actually one of the last people who could have seen Jodi alive. But that was the night before her disappearance—hours before her call with Amy in the early morning, where she seemed fine.
Either way, the police called John in for a number of interrogations. During his sessions, he admitted that he had called Jodi’s office on the morning of her disappearance to see if she’d made it in. And he made this call before she was reported missing—meaning sometime before 7:00 a.m.
John, who might be one of the last people to have seen her, called Jodi’s work to see if she was there—even though no one really knew at that point that she was missing.
Again, there didn’t seem to be any particular need for John to be talking to Jodi so early, at a time when she would’ve been busy doing her job. So it’s all just a little odd.
But when John submitted to a lie detector test, he passed. Now, we obviously know that polygraph tests are not airtight, and it is possible to pass even if you’re lying. But frankly, the police didn’t have any hard evidence against John.
In fact, when they found Jodi’s diary, they read it and learned that Jodi actually did like John and trusted him as a friend.
She never gave any indication that she was uncomfortable around him or afraid of him, nor did he have any history of behaving in a threatening way toward Jod. In fact, from the way she wrote, she really seemed to genuinely enjoy the time they spent together—including that birthday party he had thrown for her.
So yes, he's inserting himself into the investigation, and he's doing some odd things, but police didn’t have any evidence against John beyond the fact that he’d called her work and shown up at her apartment. It was odd—but not that odd for a close friend. They certainly couldn’t arrest him or name him as a suspect.
So the police classified John as a person of interest and moved on.
The good news was that the officers had plenty of other people to investigate in this case. After all, Jodi was locally famous. She appeared on the news, and virtually everyone who owned a television in that area probably knew who Jodie was—which meant that, like a lot of celebrities, Jodi sometimes got unwanted attention from her fans.
Based on some comments she had made to her friends before her disappearance, she may have also had at least one stalker.
Police learned that on October 8, 1994—about six months before her disappearance—Jodi had gone to the police and asked for their help. That day, she had noticed a white pickup truck following her around. Unfortunately, it doesn't sound like anything really came of that report. There’s no record of the investigators tracking down the truck driver or making an arrest, and Jodi also never filed any follow-up complaints.
So maybe this was a one-off incident—and not a big deal.
Except, the next spring, in March, Jodie mentioned to some friends that she had signed up for self-defense classes. She said it was because she felt like, at this point in her career, she needed some extra protection. Which isn't necessarily normal.
And then the most disturbing detail came from just one day before her disappearance. Police learned that on June 26, Jodi had been playing golf with some friends, and as they were making their way through the course, she mentioned to two of her companions that she had recently changed her phone number.
Apparently, she was getting a lot of unwanted calls on her old number. In Jodi’s own words, these calls were “nasty and naughty.” She couldn’t get the caller to leave her alone, so in the end, she had taken the only course she could—and now she had a whole new phone number.
But sadly, nobody knew who was behind all of this. Who had possibly been following her in the white truck? Who had been calling her and making her feel like she needed to learn self-defense?
Jodi’s friends didn’t even know if this was all one person. Maybe there was one prank caller, someone else following her in the truck, and some other factor that made her want to take those courses.
And it’s also worth mentioning that if Jodi did have one or more stalkers, it was impossible to know their motives. It could have been a fan who was obsessed with her after seeing her on TV. It could have been someone from her own life or social circle, or an angry ex, or someone who had romantic feelings for her and took them to an extreme.
It also could have been someone who hated Jodi because of the work she did. Remember, Jodi was a reporter. This wouldn't be the first time we've seen a reporter get hurt from things they were reporting on.
A big part of Jodi’s job was investigating powerful people and bringing uncomfortable truths to light. So maybe one of the stories she was working on had gotten her too close to someone who was dangerous.
Really, I mean, police are looking at this case and thinking, geez, the possibilities for motive are endless.
So they were basically at square one in terms of figuring out who had been making Jodi feel uneasy and frightened—and who had done this. So they began by looking at the people who were close to her, as in physically close to her: people who lived or worked near the areas where she spent a lot of her time.
And as it turned out, there were two people who lived near her apartment who had previous records as sex offenders. One of these men was a serial rapist who lived just two blocks away from Jodi, and the other man also lived nearby and had also been convicted of sex crimes.
Except when the police questioned both of these men, they both insisted they were innocent. And a lot like what had happened with John, there was no hard evidence to show that either of these men had anything to do with Jodi’s disappearance. They did have a history of violent crimes, for sure, but that didn’t automatically mean they could be blamed for every disappearance that ever happened in Mason City.
So that was probably the biggest issue with Jodi’s case: there were a lot of theories floating around, but not much evidence to support any of them. She might have been kidnapped by a friend, a stalker, a sex offender—or honestly, anyone else. The police could not rule anybody out, and they also didn’t have any clear leads to follow.
So as time went on, Jodi’s case went cold. It seemed almost impossible that this very recognizable celebrity could just vanish without a trace. And yet, to all appearances, that is exactly what Jodi did.
Six years go by, and in 2001—with no breaks or arrests—her family has Jodi legally declared dead. Obviously, this was not an easy decision for them to make, and of course, they still hoped that Jodi was alive out there somewhere. But after so long, it is hard to stay optimistic. And on top of that, there were certain legal matters they had to deal with related to her assets and bank accounts.
In order to settle her affairs, her family had no choice but to declare her dead and begin the difficult process of grieving and trying to move on.
Then, two years after that, a group of journalists launched a website called FindJodie.com. This marked more progress in the case.
Interestingly, the people who created this website were not Jodi’s friends or family members—they had never even met Jodi before her disappearance. They were journalists, just like her. Some of them had actually covered Jodi’s case on their own networks, and afterward, they just couldn’t get her story out of their heads.
One of their own had randomly disappeared, so they got together. They wanted her found, and they also wanted her to receive justice.
On this website, they posted news articles and updates. They shared videos and photos of Jodie so no one would forget her face. They kept her name alive and collected donations so they could keep advocating for her—and honestly, for other missing people.
In 2010, they decided to upgrade their website and formed a nonprofit to fund their ongoing work. As it turned out, the general public was also eager to see what they had to share. The website was very popular, and at its peak, it was getting hundreds of visitors a day.
Now, that might not sound like a lot, but keep in mind that the early 2000s were still a time when there were fewer websites and fewer people visiting them. But the FindJodie page was one of the best resources for information about this case. There were no true crime podcasts or true crime TikTok back then.
Anytime the police thought they’d made a new break, FindJodie.com was there to report on it. For example, they covered the headlines when the police subpoenaed John Vans—the friend who had made the birthday video.
This subpoena actually happened in 2017, meaning the police had reopened Jodi’s case and were probably reinvestigating early persons of interest.
Yes, 2017—meaning it had been 22 years since Jodi’s disappearance, and they were still searching for leads.
Now, the subpoena required John to give the police his fingerprints and palm print, and to share some GPS information on two different vehicles he used to own.
Unfortunately, the investigators never announced what they learned from the prints or the GPS data, if anything, and they didn’t arrest John or reclassify him from a person of interest to a suspect.
So as near as we can tell, nothing really came of this new break in 2017.
And then afterward, the case would go cold again for another seven years, which takes us to the latest set of developments in Jodi’s case, which actually all happened in the fall and winter of 2024.
Okay, so it starts in mid-October when someone made a tip to the police. Unfortunately, the officials haven’t released the tipster's identity, and we don’t know exactly what the person said either.
I think it’s safe to say that investigators in this case are keeping things tightly closed.
We do know, though, that the information on this tip led the investigators to a town called Winstead, Minnesota.
Now, Winstead is a community of about 2,200 people. Anywhere else, it would count as a small town, but in the rural Midwest, it was considered a small city.
It was also just about a half hour outside of Minneapolis, and it was 130 miles north of Mason City, where Jodie disappeared in those early morning hours.
So it wasn’t very close to her apartment, but for whatever reason, the police still thought that the information on this tip that led them to this city was worth searching.
So in November, police descended on an empty field. An apartment was under construction not too far away, but the land the police were searching was part of a public, city-owned park.
We don't know exactly what they were looking for—if they expected to find a body, a murder weapon, or a clue—but I do know that after the search was over, the police confirmed they had failed to recover any human remains. There were some animal bones, but that was to be expected in a rural, mostly empty park.
If they found anything else of interest in this recent search, they haven’t disclosed that publicly.
However, it does sound like the officials might be getting closer to learning what happened to Jod. There are definitely things going on behind the scenes that we do not know about. I’m basing that assumption in part on a statement from a man named Steve Ridge.
Steve is a private detective who has been working on Jodi’s case for a long time. According to him, when he began his investigation, he had a huge list of potential suspects. It included every person he could think of who might have had the means, motive, and opportunity to hurt Jodi back in the ‘90s.
Then Steve eliminated people from that list one by one. He was checking alibis, gathering evidence, confirming motives, and so on.
By November 16th, 2024, Steve had crossed off all but four names on the list he had made, and he was very confident that one of these four people was Jodi’s killer. He just needed a bit more evidence before he could say for sure which person was responsible.
It was tantalizing—being so close to finally having an answer.
Now, in an interview, Steve said that while investigating Jodi’s death, he uncovered what he believes to be true: Jodie was murdered by someone who had romantic feelings for her. That was his thought.
The killer was jealous because she had been seeing someone new right before she went missing.
So according to Steve, on June 17th, 1995—which is about a week and a half before her disappearance—Jodi had gone out to a bar. It was a Saturday night, and the weekend crowd was all there.
Before the night was over, Jodi struck up a conversation with a man. There was an immediate spark and an instant attraction.
Over the course of the next ten days, they went on no fewer than five dates. This is what Steve learned.
Yes, you heard that right—they went on five dates in ten days: mini golf, dinners out, and she even went over to his place at least one time. They also talked on the phone every single day.
Steve says Jodi was falling for this guy.
Interestingly, she didn’t tell many of her friends about her new man. My guess is that the relationship was still just too new—she had known him less than two weeks.
But she did mention him to one or two people, and those people actually told the police about the new boyfriend when Jodi vanished.
So while Steve was looking into this and uncovered this information that police knew about, he thinks there’s a possibility that word made it back to one of Jodi’s male friends or companions—that she was seeing someone new.
Possibly, that guy became violently possessive. This man very well might have killed Jodi once he realized that she didn’t feel the same way about him that he did about her.
In Steve's opinion, the murderer probably buried Jodi very close to the apartment where she lived—not hundreds of miles away in Minnesota, but actually somewhere within a 26-mile radius. This would mean that the tip police searched earlier does not line up with Steve's theory.
Now, Steve never said who he suspected this person was, who was so obsessed with Jodi that he might have been willing to kill her. However, the PI did make an interesting comment in a recent interview with News Nation. Steve said he thought the killer, even if caught, would probably never be convicted. Steve didn't explain how the alleged murderer would escape conviction, but it's worth mentioning that when he gave that interview, John Vans—the friend who made the birthday tape—happened to show up at the crime scene and also called her work to see if she made it in the next day.
He was in his late 60s and reportedly suffering from Alzheimer's disease, which would have made it impossible for him to ever go on trial if accused of a serious crime. So, people started putting two and two together, and given Steve's comments about the killer probably never getting a conviction and the fact that Steve thinks it was a male friend who was close to Jodi, it's possible that John was Steve's top suspect.
Now, this is not for sure; this is just what people have considered. If that was the case, I can now say with certainty that John will never face justice for Jodi’s disappearance if he was involved, because he died of natural causes on December 6th, 2024. His family kept the news quiet for a few weeks. They never released an obituary, and now we will never know what he knew, if anything, about what happened to Jod.
I know people just put two and two together thinking that John was the guy Steve was talking about, but there is another possibility out there. There is another person of interest who couldn't be convicted because he is also already dead. This man's name is Christopher Reevac, and he might be a serial killer, but it's hard to say because there are a lot of allegations about his history that are impossible to confirm.
Here's what we do know: back in 1995, Christopher's ex-wife lived in Mason City. This is the same city where Jodi went missing that same year. Obviously, this is not a super strong connection, but if Christopher was in contact with his ex and visiting her in Mason City, he might have seen Jodi on the news or even run into her on the street.
More importantly, over 10 years later, in 2006, a 21-year-old woman named Dedra Harm went missing in Wisconsin, and the circumstances of her disappearance were eerily similar to Jodi’s. Dedra was 21 years old, hitting bars with some friends, and then vanished without a trace. Months later, her body was found, and it was clear she had been murdered.
Then, a year after that, in 2007, Renee Williams also went missing, this time after leaving her shift as a bartender in a Missouri town.
In this completely separate investigation from Jodi, detectives put together a list of everyone who had been at the bar that night and who might have talked to Renee. One of her customers was Christopher. This is the same Christopher whose wife lived in Mason City, and he could have been visiting her, putting him in proximity to Jod.
Even more alarmingly, Christopher's wife came forward not long after and said that Christopher had confessed to her. He allegedly told her point-blank that he had killed Renee. In this again completely separate investigation, this was enough for the police to arrest him and put him in jail. But before his case could go to trial, Christopher took his own life, and any information he might have had died with him.
That means, to this day, they can never be sure if he really murdered Renee. It seems likely, but maybe he lied when he confessed to his wife. I mean, he was at the bar where Renee was before she died, and then his wife also came forward and said he did it, but we won't know. We’ll also never know if he had anything to do with Dedra’s murder or Jodi’s disappearance. This is just a connection people have made.
Very recently, in December of 2024, a podcast called Forgotten Wisconsin Cold Cases presented this theory—that Christopher had killed all three women. If he was responsible for these three murders, he might have committed more, too. It’s impossible to say how many victims he may have had; they are just kind of assuming that Christopher was a serial killer.
Either way, the police took those allegations very seriously and opened an investigation right away. As of this recording, we are still waiting to hear the outcome and if there is anything stronger to link Christopher to Jodi officially.
Jodi’s case is still open and unsolved, and the police are willing to explore almost any possibility. I’ll end today’s episode by saying that if you know anything about Jodi’s disappearance, officials are still accepting tips.
I’ll also say the police suspect that Christopher might have had more victims, including people who could have survived his attacks. So if you or someone you know escaped an attempted abduction in the Midwest in the ’90s or 2000s, again, please let the police know.
The Mason City Police Department can be reached at 641-421-3000, and the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation is at 515-725-6010. If you don’t have a tip and still want to help out, findjod.com does still accept donations to continue funding their work. Even a social media post could help.
The point is, there are a lot of people out there who are still looking for answers even after all these years. What we can do is spread awareness about Jodi’s case and the other cases that might be linked to hers. Hopefully, all of these efforts will pay off soon.
And that is the unsolved case of Jodi Husentrut. Thank you so much for watching or listening today, and I will see you next time as we dive further into the dark together.
Goodbye.
%20(1)%20(2).jpg)
